autopatrol
814
edits
Please remember that WiKirby contains spoilers, which you read at your own risk! See our general disclaimer for details.
Talk:Green Greens (theme): Difference between revisions
From WiKirby, your independent source of Kirby knowledge.
Jump to navigationJump to search
m
Slightly rewording reply to 1st split. Is this discussion still open?
ShadowKirby (talk | contribs) m (→Splits) |
m (Slightly rewording reply to 1st split. Is this discussion still open?) |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
The second split is about "Crystal Area", a remix of Green Greens from ''Kirby Super Star'' which received a few remixes (making them remixes of a remix), and is treated separately by HAL (e.g. 25th Anniversary Concert), and thus I believe it has an identity on its own and should be split, like [[Rest Area (theme)|Rest Area]] or [[Fountain of Dreams (theme)|Fountain of Dreams]] {{User:Superbound/sig}} 17:45, 26 January 2024 (UTC) | The second split is about "Crystal Area", a remix of Green Greens from ''Kirby Super Star'' which received a few remixes (making them remixes of a remix), and is treated separately by HAL (e.g. 25th Anniversary Concert), and thus I believe it has an identity on its own and should be split, like [[Rest Area (theme)|Rest Area]] or [[Fountain of Dreams (theme)|Fountain of Dreams]] {{User:Superbound/sig}} 17:45, 26 January 2024 (UTC) | ||
:1.Ehh...I dunno about that first split. I get that this page has a lot of music tracks, but there are also a few other pages that have many tracks like this one. Only keeping the original theme in the navbox and everything else in a gallery for | :1.Ehh...I dunno about that first split. I get that this page has a lot of music tracks, but there are also a few other pages that have many tracks like this one. Only keeping the original theme in the navbox and everything else in a gallery for this page only would seem odd to readers due to inconsistency... | ||
:2. Since this track seems to be a certain variation of a theme (and has multiple remixes), I also agree with this one being split. If "Rest Area" and "Fountain of Dreams" got their own separate pages, this theme should get one too. --[[User:Paistrie|Paistrie]] ([[User talk:Paistrie|talk]]) 18:13, 26 January 2024 (UTC) | :2. Since this track seems to be a certain variation of a theme (and has multiple remixes), I also agree with this one being split. If "Rest Area" and "Fountain of Dreams" got their own separate pages, this theme should get one too. --[[User:Paistrie|Paistrie]] ([[User talk:Paistrie|talk]]) 18:13, 26 January 2024 (UTC) | ||
:To help me and others: "Crystal Area" was in KSS ("Crystal Area"), SSBM* ("Green Greens"), KAR* ("Green Greens"), KSSU ("Crystal Area"), KTD ("Green Greens", World Map), SSB4 ("The Great Cave Offensive"), KatRC ("Deploy the Kirby Tank!"), Smashing Live*, Kirby 25th Concert ("Kirby Super Star Medley"). The ones with * I actually don't know if that Smash arrangement is based on it. Also, did I miss anything? Anyway, going to post my opinion on both better soon, just wanted to see how it would be split for "Crystal Area". {{User:Gigi/sig}} 18:25, 26 January 2024 (UTC) | :To help me and others: "Crystal Area" was in KSS ("Crystal Area"), SSBM* ("Green Greens"), KAR* ("Green Greens"), KSSU ("Crystal Area"), KTD ("Green Greens", World Map), SSB4 ("The Great Cave Offensive"), KatRC ("Deploy the Kirby Tank!"), Smashing Live*, Kirby 25th Concert ("Kirby Super Star Medley"). The ones with * I actually don't know if that Smash arrangement is based on it. Also, did I miss anything? Anyway, going to post my opinion on both better soon, just wanted to see how it would be split for "Crystal Area". {{User:Gigi/sig}} 18:25, 26 January 2024 (UTC) | ||
:Completely confused by the indentations here but anyway. Ideally I was considering a revamp in the style of [[Kirby's Triumphant Return]], with collapsible tables that should help against clutter, but I don't know if loading time will be affected. The revamp hasn't been done because the scope of it is to be determined (what to leave in the infobox). Support split of "Crystal Area", I suppose, but also, I would like to see "Re: Green Greens" get split off. Mayne if they get their own pages then we can limit ourselves to including the samples under the collapsible tables and nust that... {{User:ShadowKirby/sig}} 06:33, 27 January 2024 (UTC) | :Completely confused by the indentations here but anyway. Ideally I was considering a revamp in the style of [[Kirby's Triumphant Return]], with collapsible tables that should help against clutter, but I don't know if loading time will be affected. The revamp hasn't been done because the scope of it is to be determined (what to leave in the infobox). Support split of "Crystal Area", I suppose, but also, I would like to see "Re: Green Greens" get split off. Mayne if they get their own pages then we can limit ourselves to including the samples under the collapsible tables and nust that... {{User:ShadowKirby/sig}} 06:33, 27 January 2024 (UTC) | ||
