Automoderated users, autopatrol
18,641
edits
Talk:Kirby for Nintendo GameCube: Difference between revisions
m
no edit summary
Pinkyoshifan (talk | contribs) |
Trig Jegman (talk | contribs) mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 32: | Line 32: | ||
== Split the three games in separate pages, or more explicitly in the same page == | == Split the three games in separate pages, or more explicitly in the same page == | ||
This first came to my mind when Vipz [[User talk: | This first came to my mind when Vipz [[User talk:Zolerian Yuviaflero#"KRtDL Beta" images|pointed something to me on my talk page]], so I'd recommend checking that. This page collectively covers 3 projects which all preceded ''[[Kirby's Return to Dream Land|Return to Dream Land]]'', with that game essentially being the fourth of those games, which ended up being released instead of getting lost. That way in which the games are being covered doesn't really makes sense to me; in the [https://iwataasks.nintendo.com/interviews/wii/kirby-dream-land/0/0/ Iwata Asks] it was said that there were "three lost ''Kirby'' games", and just the first one of them was shown at that E3, while in a [https://www.ndw.jp/kirby_04/ Nintendo Dream interview], based on [https://gigi9714.wordpress.com/2021/06/03/kirby-star-allies-vol-1-interview-direct-from-yamanashi-part-1-from-the-may-2018-issue/ Gigi's translation], Kumazaki says that there were "three ''Kirby'' projects" in that 11 years spam. Thus, those three games were three separate projects, not the same project. | ||
These games aren't covered in ''Return to Dream Land''{{'}}s page because that game is a fourth separate game/project that succeeded the previous three, and thus it wouldn't make sense covering four different games in one page. But then why are these three merged here? This also may be misleading because all three are covered under "''Kirby for Nintendo GameCube''", even though that title has only ever been referred to the first one, the one shown at E3, plus that the majority of the page is focusing on that one while mentioning the later two as a secondary thing, instead of treating all three equally. We don't know if the other two ones were for the GameCube, and the third one even seemed to be for the Wii. The only reason that I could see for the later two to be merged with the first one is that the later two have just a little amount of info. The first one has a tentative name, a clean trailer, some other non-clean trailers, a bunch of screenshots, and even a page dedicated to concept art of it in ''[[20th Anniversary Kirby Pupupu Encyclopedia]]'', while the later two only have one screenshot each and are barely mentioned in one interview, and kinda acknowledged to exist in another one ([https://gigi9714.wordpress.com/2022/07/31/translation-of-the-kirby-and-the-forgotten-land-interview-from-the-june-2022-edition-of-nintendo-dream/ this interview] also barely mentions the second one). But still, even if they have almost no information of them, there is enough to draw a line and be clear that they are two different games between themselves, and between the only one that has been called ''Kirby for Nintendo GameCube''. | These games aren't covered in ''Return to Dream Land''{{'}}s page because that game is a fourth separate game/project that succeeded the previous three, and thus it wouldn't make sense covering four different games in one page. But then why are these three merged here? This also may be misleading because all three are covered under "''Kirby for Nintendo GameCube''", even though that title has only ever been referred to the first one, the one shown at E3, plus that the majority of the page is focusing on that one while mentioning the later two as a secondary thing, instead of treating all three equally. We don't know if the other two ones were for the GameCube, and the third one even seemed to be for the Wii. The only reason that I could see for the later two to be merged with the first one is that the later two have just a little amount of info. The first one has a tentative name, a clean trailer, some other non-clean trailers, a bunch of screenshots, and even a page dedicated to concept art of it in ''[[20th Anniversary Kirby Pupupu Encyclopedia]]'', while the later two only have one screenshot each and are barely mentioned in one interview, and kinda acknowledged to exist in another one ([https://gigi9714.wordpress.com/2022/07/31/translation-of-the-kirby-and-the-forgotten-land-interview-from-the-june-2022-edition-of-nintendo-dream/ this interview] also barely mentions the second one). But still, even if they have almost no information of them, there is enough to draw a line and be clear that they are two different games between themselves, and between the only one that has been called ''Kirby for Nintendo GameCube''. | ||