WiKirby:Featured Article Nomination/Failed Archive

From WiKirby
Jump to: navigation, search

Failed Featured Article Nominations

The following nominations for Featured Articles have been unsuccessful.

Waddle Dee (5 September 2010 - 31 October 2010)

It very well describes its appearances in games. Turtwig A (talk | contribs) 20:25, 5 September 2010 (CDT)

Support
Opposition
  1. It's a good article, but sadly incomplete; quite a bunch of game appearances are missing from the article, there is no section on the anime, and it could use more pictures as well to better illustrate individual appearances & types - Spear Waddle Dees for instance are mentioned, but there is no picture of them. Besides that, it is currently missing an infobox. Looking at these things, I don't think it should be featured at the moment, though I'd be willing to support once it covers the subject in greater detail; as Waddle Dees are highly characteristic enemies of the Kirby series, they deserve a more extensive coverage in my opinion.--Vellidragon 10:26, 6 September 2010 (CDT)
Neutral Comments
I'm almost ready to vote for it, I can see a few expansions to make for it. I'd like to see a section on the variants since they have different names at the end of CC at least. (Spear Waddle Dee, Fluff, Parasol, etc) (images would rock) I realize there isn't much to say about them, but it still serves to cover all of the info on them. Otherwise, I'm going to try transparenting all of the page's images, and I'll be ready to call it a winner. This would be a great article to have featured, kudos to all who have worked on it! Axiomist (talk) 22:10, 5 September 2010 (CDT)