Talk:Adeleine

Infobox music

Somewhat a minor complaint, but I don't think the TKCD remix of "Art Attack" is fitting to be considered Adeleine's theme song, as this particular arrangement isn't related specifically to her (she doesn't even appear in TKCD). Instead, I think the original K64 version might do better here. Alternatively, "Planet Popstar" might also be taken into consideration - it got remixed for her fanfare in KSA, althrough it could be considered a joint theme between Adeleine and Ribbon, so I'm mixed about this. Lastly, we can have no theme at all (N/A), like it was before. Thoughts? Superbound (talk) 13:01, 9 October 2021 (UTC)

I agree about the fact that the current theme is the worst case scenario. Between her Planet Popstar jingle (which isn't uploaded yet as I can't fin it here, though I can upload it later) and the original Art Attack, is true that Planet Popstar was probably used with both her and Ribbon in mind (altought Ribbon isn't native to Popstar, so that wouldn't represent her too much anyways), but it could also probably be used just to represent Kirby 64 in general (just like how Bandana Dee uses a remix of Kirby Wii's Home Channel theme).

If I had to say what I think that is the best case scenario, I would vote on having both of them there, as both themes has been associated with her at some point, but I don't know if that is even allowed on these types of articles. So, if one of them should be used, I would vote on Art Attack, but Bandana Dee's article uses his Dream Friend jingle, and if HAL wanted Planet Popstar remixed instead of Art Attack, I suppose that it was for something. Also, it could be just like Dedede and Meta Knight, that both have had various many themes representing them, both the recent HAL decided that King Dedede's Theme and My Friend and the Sunset are their representative themes respectively, and thus probably deciding that Planet Popstar is Adeleine's theme (and probably Ribbon's too for some reason). So by that, maybe her friend jingle would be the better option. If it is changed to Planet Popstar, I think that Art Attack should still be mentioned somewhere in her article though. -Zolerian (talk | contribs) 00:42, 10 October 2021 (UTC)

I feel like the K64 version of Art Attack would be best since it's the music that plays when encountering her for the first time and since I think that most bosses use their boss theme in their infobox. ---PinkYoshiFan 23:20, 9 December 2021 (UTC)

Bump ---PinkYoshiFan 15:23, 23 December 2021 (UTC)

Art Attack from K64 would probably be best, since the Dream Friend jingle is meant to signify both Adeleine and Ribbon, and the later versions of the Art Attack jingle are not used in conjunction with Adeleine. --Samwell (talk) 15:24, 23 December 2021 (UTC)